Disney and Netflix Are Courting Creators. YouTube Is Playing Hardball to Keep Them

Disney and Netflix Are Courting Creators. YouTube Is Playing Hardball to Keep Them
The studios are offering rich deals to grow engagement on their platforms. The Google-owned video giant is punching back with its own offers — and threats. Netflix and Disney are poaching top YouTubers with millions, but YouTube is warning creators they could lose marketing support and brand deals if they work with competitors.

The battle for the future of streaming is being fought over the creators who built their careers on YouTube.

On Sept. 23, YouTube gathered hundreds of its top creators at Pier 57 in New York City for its annual "Made on YouTube" event. But this year, the Google-owned platform wasn't the only one on attendees' minds. Netflix, Disney+, and Tubi are aggressively cutting deals for top creators, offering millions for original programming or day-and-date releases.

YouTube is not taking it lying down.

The Streaming Giants' Playbook

Netflix has been the most aggressive. After finding success licensing content from CoComelon, Ms. Rachel, and Mark Rober, the streamer expanded its outreach to food (Nick DiGiovanni), talk (Good Mythical Morning), and teen content (Alan Chikin Chow). Analyst Rich Greenfield estimates Netflix has committed upward of $1 billion to creator and podcast programming over the next three years.

Disney has followed suit, signing Dhar Mann, Dude Perfect, and Like Nastya to bolster Disney+, and hosting an event for roughly 350 creators at its studios. The appeal is both audience and economics: creators bring built-in young audiences, and one top creator told The Hollywood Reporter they can produce an hour of programming at 10% or less of the cost of a traditional scripted show—and much faster.

YouTube's Two-Pronged Counterattack

YouTube is responding with a "carrot-and-stick" approach.

The carrot is money. According to Bloomberg and Business Insider, YouTube has been offering top creators millions of dollars for exclusivity deals, requiring them to post content on YouTube for a set period before anywhere else. Payments can take the form of direct financing for shows or a share of major brand deal revenues.

The stick is access. YouTube has warned creators who sign with Netflix or post simultaneously that they could face consequences, including being excluded from YouTube marketing campaigns and events, losing invitations to high-profile events like Brandcast, and being cut off from lucrative brand partnership revenues. Some creators might even lose eligibility for the premium YouTube Select advertising program.

The Stakes

This is a fight for the future of attention. YouTube now accounts for 14.2% of U.S. television viewing, according to Nielsen, and it generated over $40 billion in advertising revenue last year. But Netflix and Disney see creator content as a way to attract younger viewers and fill their libraries with cost-effective, fast-turnaround programming.

As one industry CEO put it: "It's a very good time to be in the creator business".

Discussion

0

No comments yet

Be the first to share your thoughts on this article.