Noah Segan Explains How 'Knives Out' Helped Make 'The Only Living Pickpocket in New York' Possible
Rian Johnson made his friend Segan a promise: if 'Knives Out' works, he'll have the power to produce movies like 'Pickpocket.' That promise came true. Segan's directorial debut premiered at Sundance 2026 and opens in theaters this October.
Noah Segan's directorial debut, The Only Living Pickpocket in New York, owes its existence to a promise Rian Johnson made during the making of Knives Out.
Segan and Johnson have been collaborators and friends since Johnson cast Segan in his 2003 debut Brick. In 2018, while filming the first Knives Out, Segan showed Johnson the script for Pickpocket. Johnson's reaction was one of relief—"that his friend had not written total gobbledygook."
Then came the promise. As Segan recalled to The Hollywood Reporter: "He said, 'If things go well with this detective movie we're making, I might start to produce movies, and this is the kind of movie I could produce.'"
Johnson's read on Knives Out proved prescient. The film became a massive hit, leading Johnson and Bergman to found T-Street, the production company that would eventually shepherd Pickpocket into existence.
A Long Road to Production
The journey wasn't quick. Segan wrote Pickpocket and Blood Relatives around the same time, while home with a napping baby. When Blood Relatives took off first, Segan made that film while Pickpocket continued developing. COVID and life circumstances further delayed the project.
Segan described the emotional payoff of finally making the film with Johnson's backing: "One of the wonderful gifts that Rian bestows on his friends and collaborators is the sense that we can do it—and do it with joy and camaraderie."
The John Turturro Factor
Landing John Turturro for the lead role was another crucial piece. Segan admitted he wasn't sure who would take a chance on a small film from a relatively unknown filmmaker. But Turturro committed fully, immersing himself in research—Segan gave him books on pickpockets, including Wiz Mob, a sociological study of the profession.
Turturro connected deeply to the character of Harry, an old-school pickpocket adrift in a cashless modern New York. Segan observed: "Being a caretaker is something he talks about a lot, and I think [playing that aspect of Harry's life] really was an emotional experience for him."
A New York Story Through and Through
Segan, a fourth-generation New Yorker, fought to shoot in the city despite budget pressures to relocate. Producer Leopold Hughes recalled the debate about rebates and shooting in Serbia or Bosnia: "I was really proud that we stuck to our guns on that and made them [shoot in New York]."
The production embraced a scrappy, improvisational spirit. Segan recalled a Chinatown resident named Eddie who refused to move from his stoop. Segan finally asked, "Eddie, if I give you 20 bucks, would you go upstairs for ten minutes?" That kind of problem-solving defined the shoot.
The Release
The Only Living Pickpocket in New York premiered at Sundance 2026, where Sony Pictures Classics acquired worldwide rights. It opened in New York and Los Angeles on October 23, 2026, expanding nationwide on October 30.
For Segan, the film represents not just a career milestone but the fulfillment of a friend's belief in what they could build together. As he put it, the lesson Johnson imparts is "that we can do it—and do it with joy."
▶
▶
▶
▶
▶
▶
▶
▶
Discussion
0Join the Discussion
Sign in to share your thoughts with the Series Hub community.
Login to CommentNo comments yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this article.